OET OET-RV OET-LV GHT ULT UST BSB MSB BLB AICNT OEB WEBBE WMBB NET LSV FBV TCNT T4T LEB BBE Moff JPS Wymth ASV DRA YLT Drby RV SLT Wbstr KJB-1769 KJB-1611 Bshps Gnva Cvdl TNT Wycl SR-GNT UHB BrLXX BrTr Related Parallel Simple Interlinear Topics Reference Dictionary Search
A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W XY Z
CHRONICLES, Books of First and Second
Two OT books, historical records of King David and his successors in the land of Yehudah (Judah). The books of Chronicles are among the most neglected books in the Bible, partly because most of the material can be found in Shmuel (Samuel), Kings, or elsewhere in the OT. Fourteen chapters (1 Chr 1–9 OET CH1 1:1–54 · OET CH1 2:1–55 · OET CH1 3:1–24 · OET CH1 4:1–43 · OET CH1 5:1–26 · OET CH1 6:1–81 · OET CH1 7:1–40 · OET CH1 8:1–40 · OET CH1 9:1–44; 23–27 OET CH1 23:1–32 · OET CH1 24:1–31 · OET CH1 25:1–31 · OET CH1 26:1–32 · OET CH1 27:1–34) are little more than lists of names; the rest of the material is primarily historical narrative, which some people find almost as boring as lists. Yet the content of Chronicles is not history in a professional or academic sense because the materials used are comparable to the annals compiled by ancient Near Eastern court scribes. Those sources recorded each year’s most important events and were frequently more propagandistic than objectively historical. The records in Chronicles, somewhat eclectic in nature and ignoring certain facets of national history while emphasizing others, deal with only a selected portion of the history of the Israelis (Israelites). A good deal of the criticism that the work is historically unreliable has come from lack of understanding the book’s character. Chronicles is not so much a history as a metaphysical interpretation of events in Israeli (Israelite) life in light of covenantal values. It was not sufficient for the Chronicler that kings rose and fell; the events were interpreted from a special religious standpoint.
Preview
• Author
• Date
• Content
Author
In the Hebrew Bible, 1 and 2 Chronicles form a single book. The Bible does not say who wrote that book or when it was written. According to the Jewish Talmud, Ezra wrote “his book and Chronicles—the order of all generations down to himself.” Although many scholars defend the view that Ezra wrote Chronicles, there is still no general agreement about the date and authorship of the book.
The author is usually called “the Chronicler,” a title suggesting that he was a historian. It is possible that he was a scribe, priest, or Levite. Evidently the writer had access to government and temple archives, because repeated references are made to a number of official records of kings (1 Chr 9:1; 27:24; 2 Chr 16:11; 20:34; 25:26; 27:7; 28:26; 32:32; 33:18; 35:27; 36:8) and prophets (1 Chr 29:29; 2 Chr 9:29; 12:15; 13:22; 20:34; 26:22; 32:32; 33:19).
Jump to OET CH1 9:1 section.
Jump to OET CH1 27:24 section.
Jump to OET CH2 16:11 section.
Jump to OET CH2 20:34 section.
Jump to OET CH2 25:26 section.
Jump to OET CH2 27:7 section.
Jump to OET CH2 28:26 section.
Jump to OET CH2 32:32 section.
Jump to OET CH2 33:18 section.
Jump to OET CH2 35:27 section.
Jump to OET CH2 36:8 section.
Jump to OET CH1 29:29 section.
Jump to OET CH2 9:29 section.
Jump to OET CH2 12:15 section.
Jump to OET CH2 13:22 section.
Jump to OET CH2 26:22 section.
Jump to OET CH2 33:19 section.
The evidence is suggestive, but not conclusive, that the author of Chronicles also wrote the books of Ezra and Nehemyah (Nehemiah). The last two verses of Chronicles are almost the same as the first three verses of Ezra. The language and literary style of all three books are similar. The same theological concerns for the temple and its worship and the same interest in lists and genealogies appear in all three books. In the Hebrew Bible, Ezra-Nehemiah is considered one book and stands before Chronicles. Chronicles stands at the very end of the Hebrew Bible.
Key Places in 1 and 2 Chronicles
Date
It is not possible to determine precisely when the book of Chronicles was written. The book ends with a reference to the decree of Koresh (Cyrus), king of Paras (Persia), permitting the Jewish captives in Bavel (Babylon) to return to their homeland. Since Koresh’s decree is usually dated about 538 BC, Chronicles could not have been written before that date. But if Ezra-Nehemiah is a part of the same work as Chronicles, the materials could not have been written until Nehemyah returned to Yerushalem (Jerusalem) in 444 BC.
Genealogies in Chronicles and Ezra-Nehemiah may shed some light on the dating of the books. In 1 Chronicles 3:10-24 the lineage of David and Shelomoh (Solomon) is traced through the sixth generation after the exile, which would make the date for Anani (the last person in the list) about 400 BC.
The language of Chronicles is definitely that of postexilic Hebrew. The use of the Persian word daric (1 Chr 29:7), plus a lack of any Greek words, places Chronicles in the Persian period (538–331 BC). The word midrash (“exposition”) appears in the OT only in Chronicles (2 Chr 13:22; 24:27) but is very common in postbiblical Hebrew. Around 400 BC is probably the best estimate for the date of Chronicles, based on evidence now available.
Jump to OET CH1 29:7 section.
Jump to OET CH2 24:27 section.
Background
During the Persian period, some of the Yehudim (Jews) returned to Yerushalem from Bavel soon after Koresh’s decree. They rebuilt the temple and waited for the messianic age to come. But with drought, economic hardships, and moral and spiritual laxness, their hopes faded. Yehudah (Judah) was stable politically as a part of the large, dominant Persian Empire. There was not the slightest possibility of restoring the Davidic kingdom.
If the kingdom of David could not be restored politically, how was a Yehudi (Jew) of the early fourth century BC to understand history and the place of the Yehudim in God’s plan? The Chronicler, living at that time, found the key to history in God’s covenant with David. The first 10 chapters of 1 Chronicles lead up to David; chapters 11–29 OET CH2 11:1–23 · OET CH2 12:1–16 · OET CH2 13:1–22 · OET CH2 14:1–15 · OET CH2 15:1–19 · OET CH2 16:1–14 · OET CH2 17:1–19 · OET CH2 18:1–34 · OET CH2 19:1–11 · OET CH2 20:1–37 · OET CH2 21:1–20 · OET CH2 22:1–12 · OET CH2 23:1–21 · OET CH2 24:1–27 · OET CH2 25:1–28 · OET CH2 26:1–23 · OET CH2 27:1–9 · OET CH2 28:1–27 · OET CH2 29:1–36 detail events of David’s rule. Mosheh (Moses) is mentioned in Chronicles 31 times; David, more than 250 times. David planned the temple and collected money to build it. He appointed Levites, singers, and gatekeepers. He divided the priesthood into its orders. He was responsible for the temple worship, which was tremendously important to the Chronicler and his contemporaries.
The Persian period of Yisrael’s (Israel’s) history is largely a silent one, both in other OT materials and in archaeological finds. Of course, all the evidence is not yet in, as archaeologists continue their investigations of the period.
Origin and Purpose
The Chronicler must have lived in Yerushalem and written for the Jewish community there. He refers to Yerushalem about 240 times and to Yehudah more than 225 times. A negative feeling toward the northern kingdom of Yisrael can be seen in the almost total lack of references to any northern king. The Chronicler’s attitude toward the north is clearly expressed in the two following verses: “The northern tribes of Yisrael have refused to be ruled by a descendant of David to this day” (2 Chr 10:19, NLT) and “Don’t you realize that Yahweh, the God of Yisrael, made an unbreakable covenant with David, giving him and his descendants the throne of Yisrael forever?” (13:5, NLT).
Jump to OET CH2 10:19 section.
Jump to OET CH2 13:5 section.
The Chronicler wanted the Jewish people to see that God was sovereign over all things. For example, he includes David’s affirmation: “Yours, O Yahweh, is the greatness, the power, the glory, the victory, and the majesty. Everything in the heavens and on earth is yours, O Yahweh, and this is your kingdom. We adore you as the one who is over all things. Riches and honor come from you alone, for you rule over everything. Power and might are in your hand, and it is at your discretion that people are made great and given strength” (1 Chr 29:11-12, NLT).
Jump to OET CH1 29:11–12 section.
Compiled in the postexilic period, Chronicles was meant to emphasize the significance of the theocracy seen in light of earlier history. The theocracy was a social configuration God planned for postexilic Yehudah, a religious rather than secular community. Instead of a king, the Yehudim had a priesthood of which the Lord approved (as distinct from the corrupt priests who had been to a large extent responsible for the preexilic moral and spiritual collapse of the nation).
The postexilic Yehudim were to live as a holy nation, not as people with political and nationalistic ambitions. Therefore, the Chronicler demanded implicit obedience to the Mosaic covenant so that the returning Yehudim could find prosperity, divine blessing, and grace. The Yehudim were still the chosen people, purged by the experience of exile, with a new opportunity to fulfill the Sinay (Sinai) covenant.
The Chronicler gave great weight to divine retribution and was insistent that all action be guided by specific moral principles, to reflect God’s character clearly in his people. Because the writer saw God’s hand in all history, punishing the apostate and being gracious to the penitent, he saw in the chastened remnant of the exile the true spiritual heirs of the house of David. He insisted that the postexilic community adhere rigorously to the morality of Sinay, guarding against preexilic apostasy and ensuring divine blessing.
The writer wanted the Yehudim to know God’s power. He also wanted them to believe in the Lord so that they would be “established.” If they believed God’s messengers, they would succeed (2 Chr 20:20). He also wanted the people to know that Yerushalem (Jerusalem) was God’s chosen place of worship (2 Chr 5–6 OET CH2 5:1–14 · OET CH2 6:1–42), and that the temple, priests, singers, Levites, and gatekeepers had been divinely appointed (1 Chr 28:19). The temple was meant to be a place where all their needs could be met (2 Chr 6:19–7:3 OET CH2 6:19–42 · OET CH2 7:1–3).
Jump to OET CH2 20:20 section.
Jump to OET CH1 28:19 section.
Content
Chronicles can be briefly outlined as follows: 1 Chronicles—genealogies (1–9 OET CH1 1:1–54 · OET CH1 2:1–55 · OET CH1 3:1–24 · OET CH1 4:1–43 · OET CH1 5:1–26 · OET CH1 6:1–81 · OET CH1 7:1–40 · OET CH1 8:1–40 · OET CH1 9:1–44); the reign of David (10–29 OET CH1 10:1–14 · OET CH1 11:1–47 · OET CH1 12:1–40 · OET CH1 13:1–14 · OET CH1 14:1–17 · OET CH1 15:1–29 · OET CH1 16:1–43 · OET CH1 17:1–27 · OET CH1 18:1–17 · OET CH1 19:1–19 · OET CH1 20:1–8 · OET CH1 21:1–30 · OET CH1 22:1–19 · OET CH1 23:1–32 · OET CH1 24:1–31 · OET CH1 25:1–31 · OET CH1 26:1–32 · OET CH1 27:1–34 · OET CH1 28:1–21 · OET CH1 29:1–30); 2 Chronicles—the reign of Shelomoh (Solomon) (1–9 OET CH2 1:1–17 · OET CH2 2:1–18 · OET CH2 3:1–17 · OET CH2 4:1–22 · OET CH2 5:1–14 · OET CH2 6:1–42 · OET CH2 7:1–22 · OET CH2 8:1–18 · OET CH2 9:1–31); the kings of Yehudah (Judah) (10:1–36:21 OET CH2 10:1–19 · OET CH2 11:1–23 · OET CH2 12:1–16 · OET CH2 13:1–22 · OET CH2 14:1–15 · OET CH2 15:1–19 · OET CH2 16:1–14 · OET CH2 17:1–19 · OET CH2 18:1–34 · OET CH2 19:1–11 · OET CH2 20:1–37 · OET CH2 21:1–20 · OET CH2 22:1–12 · OET CH2 23:1–21 · OET CH2 24:1–27 · OET CH2 25:1–28 · OET CH2 26:1–23 · OET CH2 27:1–9 · OET CH2 28:1–27 · OET CH2 29:1–36 · OET CH2 30:1–27 · OET CH2 31:1–21 · OET CH2 32:1–33 · OET CH2 33:1–25 · OET CH2 34:1–33 · OET CH2 35:1–27 · OET CH2 36:1–21); epilogue on the exile and return (36:22-23). Since the Chronicler’s writings do not have a didactic format, the reader must draw out those ideas and principles that are prominent and basic.
Jump to OET CH2 36:22–23 section.
One important idea running through Chronicles is the greatness, power, and uniqueness of God. It is expressed most beautifully and forcefully in 1 Chronicles 29:11-12, which declares that everything in heaven and earth belongs to God and he is head over all. Other passages make a similar claim. When Sanheriv (Sennacherib), king of Ashur (Assyria), attacked Yehudah and Yerushalem, King Hizkiyah (Hezekiah) of Yehudah admonished his people not to fear the king of Ashur.
Several times the Chronicler repeats the idea that Yisrael’s (Israel’s) God is unique: there is no other God like the Lord. In 1 Chronicles 16:25-26, Psalm 96:4-5 is quoted: “Great is Yahweh! He is most worthy of praise! He is to be revered above all gods. The gods of other nations are merely idols, but Yahweh made the heavens!” (NLT). Both David and Shelomoh are quoted as saying that there is no other God but the Lord (1 Chr 17:20; 2 Chr 6:14).
Jump to OET CH1 16:25–26 section.
Jump to OET PSA 96:4–5 section.
Jump to OET CH1 17:20 section.
Jump to OET CH2 6:14 section.
Chronicles emphasizes that the Lord is “greater than all gods” (2 Chr 2:5). The classic passage that stresses the differences between God and the “god” of a nation is in 2 Chronicles 32. When Sanheriv attacked Yerushalem, he asked the people what they were relying on to withstand the siege in Yerushalem. Sanheriv was saying, in effect, “Don’t let Hizkiyah deceive you by telling you that your God will deliver you. No god of any nation so far has been able to stand against me. Your God is like the gods of all the other nations. He will not be able to deliver you from me.” The Chronicler observes that the Assyrians spoke of the God of Yerushalem as they spoke of the gods of the peoples of the earth. But God did deliver Hizkiyah and the inhabitants of Yerushalem from Sanheriv.
Jump to OET CH2 2:5 section.
Several passages declare that God rules over the nations (1 Chr 17:21; 2 Chr 20:6). In fact, the Chronicler saw the Lord as the one who directs history. The Lord brought Yisrael out of Mitsrayim (Egypt) and drove the Kena’anim (Canaanites) out of their land (1 Chr 17:21; 2 Chr 6:5; 20:7). Some seeming quirks of history are explained with such phrases as “it was ordained by God” (2 Chr 22:7, rsv). Over and over in telling the story of the struggles of the kings of Yehudah with other nations, Chronicles points out that the Lord always decided the battle (1 Chr 10:13-14; 18:6; 2 Chr 12:2; 13:15; 20:15; 21:11-14; 24:18; 28:1, 5-6, 19 OET CH2 28:1 · OET CH2 28:5–6 · OET CH2 28:19).
Jump to OET CH1 17:21 section.
Jump to OET CH2 20:6 section.
Jump to OET CH2 6:5 section.
Jump to OET CH2 20:7 section.
Jump to OET CH2 22:7 section.
Jump to OET CH1 10:13–14 section.
Jump to OET CH1 18:6 section.
Jump to OET CH2 12:2 section.
Jump to OET CH2 13:15 section.
Jump to OET CH2 20:15 section.
Jump to OET CH2 21:11–14 section.
Jump to OET CH2 24:18 section.
Jump to OET CH2 28:1 section. · OET CH2 28:5–6 section. · OET CH2 28:19 section.
To the Chronicler the Lord was a covenant-keeping God (2 Chr 6:14). He was the God of justice and righteousness (12:6), so human judges must judge honestly and fairly (19:7). The Chronicler made it clear that no individual or nation could succeed by opposing God (24:20); not only would people fail against God, but they were powerless without him (1 Chr 29:14; 2 Chr 20:12).
Jump to OET CH2 12:6 section.
Jump to OET CH2 19:7 section.
Jump to OET CH2 24:20 section.
Jump to OET CH1 29:14 section.
Jump to OET CH2 20:12 section.
The Lord is seen not only as a unique, righteous, and powerful God, but also as a wise God. God tests the human heart and knows when he finds integrity (1 Chr 29:17). Shelomoh prayed for God to “hear thou from heaven thy dwelling place, and forgive, and render unto every man according unto all his ways, whose heart thou knowest; (for thou only knowest the hearts of the children of men)” (2 Chr 6:30, KJB).
Jump to OET CH1 29:17 section.
Jump to OET CH2 6:30 section.
Although God knows all about human beings, and has supreme power in heaven and on earth, men and women are still free to obey or disobey the Lord. The stories in Chronicles depict people who chose to obey or disobey God. Those who obeyed succeeded; but to the extent that others, even kings, disobeyed God, they failed. Three of the Chronicler’s heroes were Yehoshafat (Jehoshaphat), Hizkiyah, and Yoshiyah (Josiah). Each was a great reformer, and each was commended for obeying the Lord. But each one sinned near the end of his life and incurred the disfavor of God. Yehoshafat joined an alliance with a wicked king from the north (2 Chr 20:35-37). Hizkiyah sinned in receiving envoys from Bavel (Babylon) and “God left him to himself” (32:31). Yoshiyah did not obey the word of God spoken by Par’oh (Pharaoh) Nekoh (Neco) and was killed (35:21-24).
Jump to OET CH2 20:35–37 section.
Jump to OET CH2 32:31 section.
Jump to OET CH2 35:21–24 section.
The Chronicler believed that all human beings have sinned (2 Chr 6:36), and should repent with all their mind and heart (6:38). One of the greatest passages on repentance in all the Bible is in 2 Chronicles 7:14.
Jump to OET CH2 6:36 section.
Jump to OET CH2 6:38 section.
Jump to OET CH2 7:14 section.
A prominent theme in Chronicles is the importance of the temple as the place to meet God in worship. One could say that almost everything in Chronicles is related to the temple in one way or another. For a person living in Yerushalem (Jerusalem) in the fourth century BC under the domination of the Persians, temple worship was very significant. The Chronicler expressed the importance of true community and institutional worship.
Worship was the dominant attitude of the Chronicler, whose God was worthy to be praised. A worship service is described in 2 Chronicles 29:20-30. Hizkiyah commanded a burnt offering and a sin offering to be made for all Yisrael. The Levites were stationed in the house of the Lord with cymbals, harps, and lyres. The priests had trumpets. “Then Hizkiyah ordered that the burnt offering be placed on the altar. As the burnt offering was presented, songs of praise to Yahweh were begun, accompanied by the trumpets and other instruments of David, king of Yisrael. The entire assembly worshiped Yahweh as the singers sang and the trumpets blew, until all the burnt offerings were finished. Then the king and everyone with him bowed down in worship. King Hizkiyah and the officials ordered the Levites to praise Yahweh with the psalms of David and Asaf (Asaph) the seer. So they offered joyous praise and bowed down in worship” (2 Chr 29:27-30, NLT).
Jump to OET CH2 29:20–30 section.
Jump to OET CH2 29:27–30 section.
See also Chronology of the Bible (Old Testament); Israel, History of; King; Kings, Books of First and Second.
Questioning the Authenticity of the Chronicles
The books of Chronicles, referred to as a single book in this article, have received considerable scholarly criticism about the nature of their content and about apparent discrepancies with material in Shmuel (Samuel) and Kings. The differences can be classified as numerical, theological, and historical.
As an example of numerical differences, 1 Chronicles 11:11 says that one of David’s “mighty men” killed 300 men with his spear at one time, but the parallel account in 2 Samuel 23:8 says he killed 800 at one time. Again, 1 Chronicles 18:3-4 says that after defeating King Hadadezer of Tsovah (Zobah), David took from him 1,000 chariots, 7,000 horsemen, and 20,000 foot soldiers; a parallel account in 2 Samuel 8:3-4 says that David took 1,700 horsemen and 20,000 foot soldiers. Although 2 Chronicles 22:2 says that Ahazyah (Ahaziah) was 42 years old when he began to reign, 2 Kings 8:26 says he was 22; and so on.
Jump to OET CH1 11:11 section.
Jump to OET SA2 23:8 section.
Jump to OET CH1 18:3–4 section.
Jump to OET SA2 8:3–4 section.
Jump to OET CH2 22:2 section.
Jump to OET KI2 8:26 section.
Many numbers in Chronicles seem exceptionally high. In 1 Chronicles 21:5, Yisrael (Israel) had just over a million men and Yehudah (Judah) had 470,000. In another example of a remarkably high number, the temple’s vestibule is said to have been 120 cubits, or approximately 180 feet (54.8 meters), in height (2 Chr 3:4). In 2 Chronicles 13:3, Yehudah’s army had 400,000 men and Yisrael’s army 800,000. Some 500,000 of Yisrael’s army were slain (2 Chr 13:17). In 2 Chronicles 14:9, Zerah the Kushi (Ethiopian) had an army of a million men and 300 chariots.
Jump to OET CH1 21:5 section.
Jump to OET CH2 3:4 section.
Jump to OET CH2 13:3 section.
Jump to OET CH2 13:17 section.
Jump to OET CH2 14:9 section.
How should such problems with numbers in Chronicles be understood? First, some of the problems in the text as it now stands may have come about from faulty copying. Also, some excessively high numbers may have been used figuratively to indicate a very large army, or perhaps as estimates. Though not all questions have been answered, scholars have found credible solutions to some of the problems. In the meantime, such matters are seen by evangelical scholars as verifying the human side of the Scriptures without necessarily detracting from their divine origin.
Chronicles also contains some different theological emphases from earlier materials. The best example can be seen by comparing 1 Chronicles 21:1 with 2 Samuel 24:1. In the Shmuel account the anger of the Lord was kindled against Yisrael, and he incited David to harm them by taking a national census. The Chronicler’s account is that “Satan stood up against Yisrael, and incited David to number Yisrael.” In one account God moved David to take the census; in the other Satan was the prime mover.
Jump to OET CH1 21:1 section.
Jump to OET SA2 24:1 section.
The authenticity of the Chronicler has also been questioned on historical grounds. Several incidents reported in Samuel-Kings are told in a different manner in Chronicles. In 2 Samuel 8:13 David is said to have slain 18,000 Edomim (Edomites) at the Valley of Salt, whereas the Chronicler reports that Avishay (Abishai), David’s cousin, killed the Edomim (1 Chr 18:12). Again, according to 2 Samuel 21:19, Elhanan slew Galyat (Goliath) the Giti (Gittite), whereas the Chronicler says that Elhanan slew Lahmi, the brother of Galyat the Giti (1 Chr 20:5; most OT scholars today believe that Chronicles preserves the true reading of the original text). A more difficult historical problem is seen by comparing 2 Chronicles 20:35-37 with 1 Kings 22:48-49. The Kings account says that the ships Yehoshafat (Jehoshaphat), king of Yehudah, built to bring gold from Ofir (Ophir) were wrecked at Etsyon-Gever (Ezion-geber), evidently before they ever left port. When Ahazyah, king of Yisrael, asked that his servants be allowed to go on the ships with Yehoshafat’s servants, Yehoshafat refused. The Chronicler’s version of what happened is different. There Yehoshafat joined with the wicked Ahazyah in building ships at Etsyon-Gever to go to Tarshish, but a prophet prophesied that the Lord would destroy the ships because of the alliance with Ahazyah. Both accounts agree that Yehoshafat built ships at Etsyon-Gever and that the ships were destroyed before they left port. On the basis of the present status of the texts, however, one cannot tell whether or not Yehoshafat joined Ahazyah. Whatever happened, the ships were lost.
Jump to OET SA2 8:13 section.
Jump to OET CH1 18:12 section.
Jump to OET SA2 21:19 section.
Jump to OET CH1 20:5 section.
Jump to OET KI1 22:48–49 section.
In a comparison of Chronicles with Kings, a serious problem arises over the war between Asa of Yehudah and Baesha (Baasha) of Yisrael. In 2 Chronicles 16:1 one reads that in Asa’s 36th year of reign, Baesha challenged Yehudah by building a fortress at Ramah. But according to the chronology of 1 Kings 16, Baesha was not even alive in the 36th year of Asa’s reign. First Kings 16:6-8 says that Baesha died and his son Elah succeeded him as king in the 26th year of Asa’s reign.
Jump to OET CH2 16:1 section.
Jump to OET KI1 16:6–8 section.
At one time scholars were quite skeptical about the authenticity of Chronicles. Now they tend to treat Chronicles with respect and appreciation. In some instances new archaeological evidence has tended to support the historicity of the Chronicler’s statement. In other instances reexamination of a discrepancy has shown it to be more apparent than real. If all the facts were known, other problems might also be cleared up to the satisfaction of impartial scholars.